Choosing the right ducted heating system for a Melbourne home means understanding the tradeoffs between fuel type, efficiency, running cost, and Victorian energy policy. This comparison covers gas ducted, reverse-cycle refrigerative ducted, and hydronic heating — and the critical difference Victoria's gas ban on new connections makes to your decision.
The three main ducted heating types
| Type | How it works | Best for |
|---|---|---|
| Gas ducted heating | Gas burner heats air; fan circulates through ducts to all rooms | Homes already on natural gas; fast warm-up; cost-effective to run |
| Reverse-cycle refrigerative ducted | Heat pump moves heat from outside air into home; also cools in summer | All-electric homes; new builds; both heating and cooling from one system |
| Hydronic heating | Gas, heat pump or solar boiler heats water; radiator panels or in-slab pipes distribute warmth | Renovations, new builds; radiant comfort; quiet operation |
Gas ducted heating
How it works
A gas burner heats air in a heat exchanger. A fan circulates the warmed air through sheet metal or flexible ductwork to ceiling or floor registers in each room. Zone controllers allow individual rooms or wings to be independently controlled.
Efficiency
Modern gas ducted units have 5–7 star energy ratings under the Australian gas appliance star rating scheme. High-efficiency condensing units (Brivis NC+ range, Rinnai Ducted series) recover latent heat from flue gases and achieve up to 95% thermal efficiency.
Running cost in Melbourne
At 2026 Melbourne natural gas rates (~$0.03–$0.04/MJ), a well-insulated 4-bedroom home with 7-star gas ducted heating costs approximately $600–$900/year for winter heating. Actual costs depend heavily on insulation, thermostat setpoints, and zone usage.
Victorian gas ban context
Important: Victoria's gas new connection ban
From 1 January 2024, Victoria banned new natural gas connections in newly constructed residential buildings. If your home does not already have a gas connection, you cannot add one for a ducted gas heater. Replacing an existing gas ducted system with a newer gas system remains permitted.
Reverse-cycle refrigerative ducted
How it works
A refrigerant circuit extracts heat from outdoor air (even down to -15°C) and concentrates it indoors via a heat pump cycle. The same system reverses in summer for cooling. All heat exchange happens in the outdoor unit; the indoor unit circulates conditioned air through ducts.
Efficiency
Modern inverter-driven reverse-cycle ducted systems have COP (coefficient of performance) of 3–5, meaning they deliver 3–5 units of heat energy per unit of electricity consumed. This makes them significantly more efficient than resistive electric heating.
Running cost comparison
At Melbourne electricity rates (~$0.35–$0.40/kWh in 2026) and a COP of 3.5, a reverse-cycle system costs approximately 10–11c per kWh of delivered heat, compared to 3–4c/kWh for gas at current rates. Gas remains cheaper to run in 2026 — but this gap is narrowing as electricity prices fall with renewable penetration and gas prices rise.
Best scenario for reverse-cycle ducted
- New builds or major renovations (no existing gas infrastructure)
- Homes planning rooftop solar — self-generated electricity shifts the economics significantly
- All-electric homes future-proofing against gas network charges
- Climate zones requiring both heating and cooling (reverse-cycle handles both)
Hydronic heating
How it works
A boiler (gas, heat pump, or solar-assisted) heats water to 40–80°C. Circulating pumps distribute hot water to panel radiators, fan-coil units, or in-slab/in-floor heating circuits. Each circuit can be independently controlled.
Comfort advantage
Radiant hydronic heating (floor or panel) provides a notably different comfort feel to ducted air heating — it warms surfaces and objects rather than primarily heating air. This eliminates the dry air, dust circulation, and noise associated with fan-forced air systems.
Limitations
- High installation cost: $15,000–$40,000 for in-slab systems in new homes
- Retrofit to existing homes is expensive and disruptive
- Panel radiator retrofits ($8,000–$20,000) are more feasible for existing homes
- No cooling function (separate cooling system required)
- Slow heat-up time compared to ducted air (floor thermal mass takes hours)
Comparison summary: which system for Melbourne?
| Factor | Gas ducted | Reverse-cycle ducted | Hydronic |
|---|---|---|---|
| New builds (no gas) | Not permitted | ✅ Recommended | ✅ Heat pump boiler |
| Existing gas homes | ✅ Simple replacement | ✅ Gas removal option | Possible, expensive |
| Both heat and cool | Heat only | ✅ Yes | Heat only |
| Running cost 2026 | Lowest | Moderate | Varies by boiler |
| Comfort quality | Good | Good | Best (radiant) |
| Install cost | $4,000–$8,000 | $6,000–$14,000 | $8,000–$40,000 |
Melbourne climate and ducted heating type selection
Why gas ducted heating dominates Melbourne homes
Melbourne’s winters are cold enough to require effective heating (average July low 6°C, with regular sub-4°C nights in outer suburbs) but mild enough that a well-sized gas ducted system handles heating comfortably. Natural gas network coverage across Melbourne’s established suburbs historically made gas ducted heating the dominant choice from the 1970s through 2010s. Today, gas tariff increases and federal policy changes mean new all-electric ducted reverse-cycle systems are growing in popularity, particularly in energy-efficient homes and new builds.
Ducted heating and Victoria’s minimum energy efficiency standards
The National Construction Code (NCC) 2022 sets minimum energy efficiency standards for heating and cooling systems in new residential builds. For replacement systems in existing Melbourne homes, there is no mandatory minimum star rating, but the Victorian Energy Upgrades (VEU) program offers financial incentives for upgrading to high-efficiency systems including:
- High-efficiency ducted gas heating (6-star rated or above)
- Ducted reverse-cycle air conditioning replacing gas heating (significant VEU incentive)
- Zoned ducted systems replacing older non-zoned units
The VEU rebate is applied at point of sale by your installer — you don’t need to apply separately. When getting quotes, ask each installer whether they are a registered VEU activity provider and whether your upgrade qualifies.
Ducted heating in heritage-overlay Melbourne properties
Properties in Melbourne’s heritage overlay (common in inner suburbs like Carlton, Fitzroy, South Yarra, Toorak) may have restrictions on external works visible from the street. Outdoor condenser units, roof penetrations, and external flue locations may require a planning permit for heritage properties. Your HVAC installer should advise on this. 24/7 Service Mate’s technicians are familiar with Melbourne council requirements and can advise on siting and installation requirements before work begins.
Ducted heating lifespan and replacement signs for Melbourne homeowners
Most ducted gas heaters in Melbourne last 15–20 years with annual servicing. Signs that a replacement is due include: frequent breakdown requiring expensive repairs, heat exchanger cracks confirmed by a technician, star rating below 3.5 stars (significant operating cost disadvantage vs modern 5–7 star units), and parts no longer available (common for units older than 20 years). When replacing, the ductwork, grilles, and zone controls can often be retained, reducing the replacement cost. 24/7 Service Mate provides free, no-obligation replacement quotes and can install a new unit with same-week turnaround in most Melbourne suburbs. Call 1300 24 11 47 to book an assessment.
FAQ
- Can I replace my old gas ducted heater with a new gas model in Melbourne?
- Yes, if you already have a gas connection, you can replace like-for-like or upgrade to a higher-efficiency gas ducted system. The ban only applies to new gas connections in new builds.
- What brands of gas ducted heating are most common in Melbourne?
- Brivis, Rinnai, Braemar, Pyrox, and Bonaire are the dominant brands in Melbourne homes. All are manufactured or assembled in Australia and have good local service networks.
Related reading
For local help, see our Melbourne HVAC services, HVAC technician in Richmond, HVAC technician in St Kilda. Our ducted air conditioning page covers scope, pricing and 24/7 dispatch. Emergency? See our emergency HVAC repair in Richmond. Related guides: Ducted Heating Service Cost Melbourne 2026: What Is Included, Ducted heating not heating evenly - zone setup mistakes most Melbourne homes have.